Questions That Answer Themselves: 谁不想去?
反问句2:由疑问代词构成的反问句
Make a point strongly with 谁, 哪儿, 怎么 and 什么 in questions
The question word stands where it would in a real question, and the sentence means the opposite of what it asks: 谁不知道?, who doesn't know?, means everyone knows. As a rule of thumb, a question with 不 says everyone or always, and one without says no one, nowhere or never. 呢 or 啊 can end it, and 吗 does not.
The situation and the tone tell a rhetorical question from a real one: 你去哪儿? asks, and 我哪儿有时间? does not.
Lesson targets
Podcast
Podcast: Questions That Answer Themselves: 谁不想去? (反问句2:由疑问代词构成的反问句)
Listen to Jason & Amy explain the 反问句2:由疑问代词构成的反问句 pattern
New here?
Understanding 反问句2:由疑问代词构成的反问句
A question word does not always ask. HSK 3's Any and Every with Question Words showed 谁都知道, everyone knows, and HSK 3's 不是……吗? showed a question that asks nothing. Here a question word makes a question that needs no answer, and the sentence means the opposite: 谁不想去?, who wouldn't want to go?, means everyone would. 我哪儿有时间? means I have no time at all; 哪儿 asks about no place. 我怎么知道? means I can't possibly know, and 这怎么行? means that won't do. 这有什么难的? says it isn't hard at all, and 我什么时候说过? says I never said it. 呢 or 啊 often ends the sentence; 吗 does not, because the question word already asks. The tone can be sure, impatient or even rude, so these questions suit friends and family more than strangers.
Key Points
- A question word in a question that needs no answer means the opposite of what it asks.
- 谁 with 不 means everyone: 谁不想去? 谁 without 不 means no one: 谁还会来呢?
- 哪儿 before 有 or a verb means not at all: 我哪儿有时间? It asks about no place.
- 怎么 means how could: 我怎么知道?, I can't know; 这怎么行?, that won't do.
- 有什么 + adjective + 的 means not at all: 这有什么难的? 这有什么关系? means it doesn't matter.
- 什么时候 + verb + 过 means never: 我什么时候说过?
- 呢 or 啊 can end the sentence, and 吗 does not: the question word already asks.
- HSK 3's X什么(啊), as in 哭什么, is a pattern of its own, and 难道……吗? has its own page.
Key Vocabulary
Example Sentences
这么好的地方,谁不想去?
Who wouldn't want to go somewhere this nice?
谁 with 不: everyone would.
这么晚了,谁还会来呢?
Who'd come at this hour?
谁 without 不: no one will.
作业这么多,我哪儿有时间看电视?
With all this homework, where would I find time for TV?
哪儿 asks about no place: I have no time.
这么贵的车,我哪儿买得起?
How could I ever afford a car this expensive?
他去哪儿了,我怎么知道?
How should I know where he's gone?
他去哪儿了 is what I can't know; 怎么 makes the point.
你一个人去?这怎么行?
On your own? That won't do.
你不说,别人怎么会知道呢?
If you don't say, how will anyone know?
这有什么难的?我教你。
What's so hard about it? I'll show you.
It isn't hard at all.
我什么时候说过我不去?
When did I ever say I wasn't going?
什么时候 + 过: I never said it.
没考好,这有什么关系?下次努力就行了。
So the exam didn't go well. What does it matter? Work hard next time and you'll be fine.
Common Mistakes
The question word already makes the question, so 吗 goes. 啊 or 呢 can end it.
Without 不, 谁想去? asks who wants to go, or says that no one does. For everyone, add 不.
怎么 goes before the verb.
哪儿 goes before 有, in a question. For a plain statement, say 我没有时间.
Practice Exercises
Tips & Tricks
Turn it round: the question says the opposite of what it means. 谁不知道? means everyone knows.
Listen for the tone: a real question waits for an answer, and a rhetorical one sounds sure.
Keep these for friends and family. To a teacher or a stranger, 我怎么知道? can sound rude.
Homework
Write six questions that answer themselves, two each with 谁, 哪儿 and 怎么, and after each write in English what it really means. For example: 这么好的天气,谁想在家里? (No one wants to stay in.)
Ask Jason
Have a question about Questions That Answer Themselves: 谁不想去? (反问句2:由疑问代词构成的反问句)?
Jason explains this pattern at your level, gives you more examples and checks your own sentences.
Sign in free to ask. New accounts start with 200 AI credits.
A sample week, replayed. Every page you study lands here in the order you did it — your own replay starts with a free account.
See the Learning Lab